On 'World' Music
5 min read
Planted: Mid 2024
Last tended to: 2 months ago
“World music” is the label for anything outside the Western tradition, which makes it a definition by exclusion, and it has been contested for years. At first glance it looks harmless, generous even. What it does is put everything that is not Western into one box and call the box a genre.
When we refer to non-Western music as “world music,” we are, perhaps unwittingly, imposing a cultural hierarchy. This classification subtly suggests that Western music is the norm, the universal benchmark, while music from other parts of the world is relegated to a special, niche category. This isn’t just an issue of semantics; it’s a reflection of a deeper, more insidious mentality that has its roots in colonialism. The narrative that non-Western cultures and their artistic expressions are somehow secondary or lesser than their Western counterparts is an outdated notion, yet it continues to echo through our contemporary classifications and discussions.
Take, for example, my own interactions with music. Whenever I add new tracks from diverse cultures to my Apple Music library, I make it a point to change the ‘World’ genre category. It might seem like a small gesture, but it’s my way of rejecting this implicit hierarchy. It’s a personal stance against a classification system that, in my view, does more harm than good.
The hierarchy is the first problem and the flattening is the larger one. Indian classical raga, Colombian cumbia and Nigerian Afrobeat each carry their own history, their own rules, their own significance to the people who made them. Filing all three under one word says those differences were never important enough to record.
This oversimplification isn’t just an academic concern; it has real-world implications for the musicians and their communities. When we fail to acknowledge the diversity within the “world music” category, we are effectively erasing the individuality of these artists. They become faceless representatives of an exotic other, rather than respected musicians in their own right. This can impact how they are viewed and valued, both within their communities and on the global stage.
Moreover, the commercialization of non-Western music under the umbrella of “world music” often leads to economic exploitation. The global music industry, driven by profit and marketability, tends to commodify these musical traditions. Artists from non-Western countries are frequently underpaid and undervalued, their music repackaged and sold without them seeing fair financial return. In some cases, the unique aspects of their music are watered down or altered to make them more palatable to Western audiences, stripping away the essence of the original art form.
This commodification is closely tied to the issues of cultural appropriation and misrepresentation. In the quest to make non-Western music more marketable, elements are often borrowed out of context, leading to a superficial and sometimes disrespectful portrayal of these cultures. When Western artists incorporate sounds or styles from non-Western music without a deep understanding of their cultural significance, they risk perpetuating stereotypes and misrepresentations.
In my journey as a music enthusiast, I have witnessed how cultural appropriation in music is not just about borrowing sounds or instruments; it’s about power dynamics. It’s about who gets to tell the story and who profits from it. When Western artists use elements of non-Western music in their work without proper credit or understanding, they contribute to a narrative that devalues the original creators and their cultural heritage.
So, what’s the alternative? There’s a growing movement within the music industry and among scholars and enthusiasts to rethink the way we categorize and discuss global music. This movement calls for abandoning the term “world music” in favour of more specific and respectful terminology. Rather than lumping diverse musical traditions into one vague category, we should strive to recognize and appreciate the individuality of each. This change goes beyond mere words; it’s about adopting a new perspective, one that values cultural exchange and understanding oversimplification and commodification.
Dropping the term changed how I listen. It sent me to the stories behind the songs, the histories of the instruments, the lives of the artists, and mostly it showed me the size of what I do not know. That was humbling in a useful way. None of it means enjoying this music less. It means the enjoyment comes with some homework, and with supporting the artists directly where I can.
Music education is where the hierarchy gets installed. Western classical and popular music dominate the curriculum and everything else gets whatever room is left. Teach a wider range of traditions with the same depth and seriousness given to Western music and it stops reproducing itself.
“Universal language” is the compliment everyone reaches for, and it is the accents and dialects that carry the meaning. Listening closely gets you the notes and rhythms, and the people and places behind them, the struggles and the celebrations. That is where the empathy comes from, in a world this connected and this divided, and it is worth doing with both joy and responsibility.